The earthing arrangement decides the path a fault current takes and whether protection sees it. The neutral decides whether that path stays the same when the load moves from the mains to the set. The governing rule: an interconnected system has exactly one neutral-to-earth bond, and whether the neutral is solid or switched follows from where that bond sits.
What the earthing arrangement actually decides
The earthing arrangement is not a property of the set. It is a property of the installation the set is connected to, and it settles three things at once: where the neutral is bonded to earth, what loop a fault current takes, and what the supply does on a first earth fault. Take one of those three as given and the protection settings, the cable sizes and the changeover design all rest on a wrong premise.
| Question | What settles it | What it changes downstream |
|---|---|---|
| Where is the neutral bonded to earth? | The earthing system of the installation, and how many sources feed it | Whether the neutral can stay solid through a changeover or has to be switched |
| What loop does a fault current take? | The bond point, the protective conductor and the electrode | The size of the earth-fault current and whether a device operates inside its time |
| What happens on a first earth fault? | The system type, TN, TT or IT | Whether the supply trips off or keeps running with a fault on it |
This is why the arrangement belongs on the single-line diagram before the set is ordered, and why it belongs in the enquiry. The same 500 kVA set behaves differently on a TN-S board with a single bond and on an IT board with insulation monitoring and no bond at all, and the changeover that suits one is wrong for the other.
TN-S, TN-C-S, TT and IT: what each expects of a set
The four names describe how the source is earthed and how the protective conductor reaches the load, and they are fixed by the installation rather than chosen by the set. Each one asks a different question of the set’s neutral, which is the reason the system type has to be stated on the drawing.
| System | How it is earthed | What it expects of the set | Where it is usually met |
|---|---|---|---|
| TN-S | The source has one neutral-to-earth bond, and the neutral and the protective earth run as separate conductors all the way | The set is a second source on the same earthed system; its own neutral is usually left unbonded and the single bond stays at the mains origin | Boards where the distributor brings in a separate neutral and earth |
| TN-C-S, also called PME | The neutral and the earth are combined for part of the run and split into separate neutral and protective earth at the origin | Many supply authorities do not permit a generator neutral bond to be exported onto the distributor earth; the bond stays at the origin, which pushes the changeover towards four poles | Urban supplies where the distributor provides a combined conductor |
| TT | The installation has its own earth electrode, separate from the source earth | The set’s own electrode and the protection, usually residual-current based, have to be coordinated; the neutral may be bonded at the set as a separately derived system | Sites with no distributor earth, or where the distributor earth is not dependable |
| IT | The source is isolated from earth, or connected to earth through a high impedance | A first earth fault does not trip; insulation monitoring is used, and the neutral is not bonded | Special process, marine and some medical supplies |
For an off-grid or exported site the TT case is the common one, and the practical version is an earth electrode driven at the set and bonded to the frame, which is what the trailer-mounted diesel generator page describes. Whether the neutral is brought out of the machine at all, and how it is labelled in the terminal box, is a separate point covered in generator voltage and phases. Whichever system applies, write it on the drawing, because the same neutral decision runs through the changeover, the protection and the cable.
The single bond rule: one neutral-to-earth bond in the system
One interconnected system has exactly one neutral-to-earth bond. If a second bond appears, part of the neutral return current leaves the intended path and returns through the general mass of earth and any parallel metalwork. That current is not measured by a residual-current device, it can corrode buried metal over time, and it puts a small voltage between earth points that are supposed to be at the same potential.
The usual way a second bond appears is a generator whose neutral is bonded inside the set, connected through a three-pole changeover to a mains supply that is also bonded at its origin. While the set runs as standby on the same system there are two bonds on one system. The answer is one of two moves: leave the set’s neutral unbonded, which keeps one bond at the mains origin and usually calls for three poles, or switch the neutral so that the two systems are never bonded at the same moment, which calls for four poles. The changeover side of that argument is set out in ATS vs AMF; this page comes at it from the earthing.
A separately derived system is the other legitimate arrangement. Its own neutral-to-earth bond makes it a source in its own right, and the bond is created at the set, at the alternator neutral terminal or on the earth bar beside it. That is a correct arrangement, not a fault. What is not correct is two bonds on one interconnected system, whoever created them.
Where the bond goes: at the set, at the switchboard, or nowhere
The bond has three legitimate positions, and choosing between them is a design decision that has to be taken before the switchboard is ordered. It is also the decision that fixes the changeover, so the two are usually taken together.
| Where the bond sits | When it is used | What it means for the changeover |
|---|---|---|
| At the mains origin only, with the set’s neutral left unbonded | The set is a standby source on the same earthed system as the mains, one earthed system | Three poles are usually enough; the neutral stays solid and there is no second bond to interrupt |
| At the set, as a separately derived system | Off-grid or exported sites, or where the set has to be independent of the mains earthing | Four poles, so that the set’s bonded neutral and the mains neutral are never connected at the same time |
| Nowhere, with both neutrals unbonded | IT supplies and some process supplies, where a first fault must not shut the supply down | The neutral stays unbonded on both sides, and insulation monitoring replaces the earth-fault trip |
One variant catches people out: the set with a link fitted across the alternator neutral terminals. It leaves the works bonded, and the site is expected to remove the link if the installation already has its own bond. If the link stays in place, a three-pole changeover on a bonded mains supply creates the second bond. Ask for the link to be identified and the neutral arrangement to be stated, so the site knows whether to take it out.
Solid neutral or switched neutral: what actually changes
A solid neutral runs through the changeover without being switched: the phases change over, the neutral does not. A switched neutral is a pole in the changeover that makes and breaks with the phases. Neither is better than the other in itself; each matches a different bonding arrangement, and the mismatch is what causes trouble.
| Point | Solid neutral, usually three-pole | Switched neutral, four-pole |
|---|---|---|
| What moves in the changeover | The three phases only | The three phases and the neutral together |
| While one source feeds the load | The two neutrals stay tied together all the time | The two neutrals are connected only for the source that is in use |
| Works with | One neutral-to-earth bond on the whole system | Two separately bonded sources, one bond each, isolated from one another |
| Neutral current | The unswitched neutral carries the harmonic current of whichever source is running | The neutral pole carries the same current and has to be rated for it |
| Fails when | Any second bond appears anywhere on the system | The neutral pole is undersized, or does not make and break with the phases |
The neutral current on a generator supply is often higher than intuition suggests. Triplen harmonics from single-phase electronic loads add in the neutral rather than cancelling, so on a board full of switch-mode supplies and LED drivers the neutral can approach, and in the worst case exceed, the phase current. On a three-pole device the neutral is a permanent connection and is usually sized for that; on a four-pole device the neutral pole carries the same current and has to be specified for it. The harmonic question and the conductor sizing are worked through in generator cable sizing and voltage drop.
Four poles or three: the answer, in order
The choice is not a preference and it is not a rule of thumb. It resolves from the system, and the questions are best taken in order, because the first one that answers yes closes the decision.
| In order | The question | If the answer is yes |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Is the set a separately derived system, with its own neutral-to-earth bond at the set? | Four poles. Two bonds on one interconnected system put part of the return current on the earth path |
| 2 | Do the supply rules forbid exporting a generator neutral bond onto the distributor earth, as on a TN-C-S supply? | Four poles, with the bond kept at the origin and the set’s neutral switched |
| 3 | Is there a residual-current device or an earth-fault relay in the essential board? | Four poles. A solid neutral gives the device a return path it cannot measure, so it trips without a fault or fails to trip on one |
| 4 | Is there more than one source, or a large UPS or harmonic load? | Four poles. Each source has to be isolated while it is not in use, and the neutral pole has to be rated for the harmonic current |
| 5 | None of the above, and the set is a standby on a single earthed system | Three poles are usually enough. The neutral stays solid and the single bond stays at the mains origin |
Two requirements follow on a four-pole device, and both are checked on the drawing rather than on the datasheet. The neutral has to make and break with the phases, not before or after them, because a neutral switched out of step produces exactly the problem the four-pole device was bought to prevent. And the neutral pole, together with the neutral bar and the cabling around it, has to be rated for the full load and for the harmonic current. Where the changeover itself is being specified, the device types and the amp ratings are set out in ATS vs AMF.
- Two bonds on one system. The second bond is usually a link left in at the alternator, or a set bonded at the works and connected to a bonded mains. It shows up as nuisance trips, unexplained standing current or slow corrosion.
- A solid neutral behind a residual-current device or an earth-fault relay. The device has a return path it cannot see, so it either trips without a fault or stays closed through one.
- A four-pole device with an unrated neutral pole. The neutral carries load current and harmonic current just as the phases do, and an undersized pole overheats and drops voltage on the neutral.
The three are worth stating in the enquiry before the drawing is issued, because each one is cheap to decide on paper and expensive to correct in a built board.
What an earth fault looks like on a generator supply
An earth fault on a generator supply is not a smaller version of the same fault on a transformer supply; it is a different shape. The generator’s fault current is limited by the alternator itself, and it decays, which is what the protection has to be arranged around.
| Point | A generator supply | A transformer supply |
|---|---|---|
| What limits the fault current | The alternator, mainly its subtransient reactance, which is high in per-unit terms | The transformer impedance, usually much lower in per-unit terms |
| Size of the fault current | A few times the rated current, not tens of times | Commonly ten times the rated current or more |
| How long it lasts | It decays within a few cycles as the machine is driven down | It is held up by the supply behind the transformer |
| What that means for protection | An overcurrent device set for a transformer case may not operate in time, so earth-fault protection is used with a low setting | Overcurrent protection alone can often clear the fault |
The practical consequence is that earth-fault protection on a generator supply is set from the earthing and neutral arrangement rather than from a standard table. That arrangement decides how much current a fault actually produces; the protection then decides how quickly to act on it. The relay side of that, settings in the range of 10 to 20 % of rated current with a delay of 0.5 to 5 seconds, is set out in generator control panel and protections. What this page adds is the upstream point: change the bond and the fault current the relay sees changes with it, so the two decisions cannot be taken apart.
RCDs, earth-fault relays and more than one source
A residual-current device works on the difference between the current going out in the phases and the current coming back in the neutral. On a generator supply two things upset that measurement: a second neutral path to earth, and the waveform of the machine itself.
| Device | What it measures | What defeats it on a generator supply |
|---|---|---|
| Residual-current device, RCD | The residual current between the phases and the neutral | A solid neutral with a second bond gives the device a return path it cannot measure; some types also struggle with the non-sinusoidal or direct component of a generator supply |
| Earth-fault relay with a core-balance current transformer | The residual current around the phases and the neutral, measured as a group | The same second-bond problem, and a setting that has to suit the limited fault current of the set |
| Earth-fault relay on the earthing conductor | The current in the earthing conductor itself | A correctly bonded single-earthed system carries no standing current there; a second bond puts standing current on that path and the relay sees the difference |
The same rule scales up. Two sets running in parallel, or a set and a shore supply, form one interconnected system while they are connected, and that system can have only one neutral-to-earth bond. The parallel case is covered in generator paralleling, where the single bond is what keeps the return current where it belongs. Where two separate sources are not paralleled but change over, four poles keep them isolated so that each bond belongs to one source at a time. Where the essential board is an IT distribution, as it often is in data centre backup power, the same single-bond rule holds and the insulation monitoring takes the place of the earth-fault trip.
Mobile, trailer and temporary supplies
A trailer or skid set is usually the case where the earthing arrangement is settled on site, and it is worth stating on the drawing and on the machine. The common practical arrangement is an earth electrode driven at the set and bonded to the frame, with the neutral arrangement declared on the set, so that the site is not left to guess whether the neutral is bonded. A set that travels as freight and is then connected to a shore or building supply, as a containerised diesel generator often is, meets exactly the same question on arrival.
On a temporary site supply there are two workable patterns. The first treats the set as a separately derived system: bond the neutral to earth at the set, add the electrode, and provide the protection at the set. The second runs the set with its neutral unbonded on an IT-type system and monitors the insulation, which keeps the supply running through a first fault where a shutdown would be worse than the fault. The arrangement to avoid is a set bonded at the set and connected, through a three-pole changeover, to a bonded mains supply: that is the second bond again, with the return current split between the neutral and the earth.
None of this should be fixed from a web page, and a few limits are worth stating. The distributor’s rules on TN-C-S supplies vary and have to be confirmed with the supply authority rather than assumed. The fault current and the protection settings have to be calculated for the actual alternator, cable and board, not taken from a generic table. And a set that will later be paralleled, or later joined by a second source, has to have its earthing reviewed again, because a decision that was right for a single standby set can become wrong the moment a second source appears.
Questions about earthing and the neutral
Is a four-pole changeover always required?
No. Three poles are usually enough where the set is a standby on a single earthed system with one neutral-to-earth bond at the mains origin and no Residual-current device in the essential board. Four poles are called for when the set is a separately derived system with its own bond, when the supply rules forbid exporting a generator bond onto a combined neutral and earth supply, when the board has an RCD or an earth-fault relay, or when there is more than one source. The decision follows from the system, so the earthing has to be known first.
What is a switched neutral?
A switched neutral is a changeover pole that makes and breaks the neutral at the same time as the three phases. It keeps the set’s bonded neutral and the mains neutral apart, so the two are never connected at once, which is what makes it possible to run two separately bonded sources into one board. On a solid neutral, the neutral runs through unswitched and the two neutrals are tied together permanently, which is correct only where the whole system has a single bond.
Should the generator neutral be bonded at the set?
Only when the set is a separately derived system, that is, when it is the source of an installation with its own earthing rather than a second source on a system that is already bonded. Where the installation has one bond at the mains origin, the set’s neutral is left unbonded and any link across the alternator neutral terminals is removed. Sets are often shipped with that link in place, so the arrangement has to be stated on the nameplate or the drawing and checked on site.
Why does the RCD trip when the set takes over?
Usually because a second neutral-to-earth bond has appeared and part of the return current is bypassing the device. A residual-current device compares the current in the phases with the current in the neutral, and a parallel earth path gives it a difference it reads as a fault, so a 30 mA device can trip on a healthy circuit. The same second bond can also hold the device closed through a real fault. Confirm the number of bonds before changing the device.
What is a TN-S generator supply?
TN-S describes the installation, not the set. The source has a single neutral-to-earth bond and the neutral and the protective earth run as separate conductors to the load. A generator working as a standby into a TN-S board is a second source on that same earthed system, so its neutral is normally left unbonded and the one bond stays at the mains origin. Sizing the neutral and the protective conductor for that supply is a separate exercise, covered in generator cable sizing and voltage drop.
Can two generator neutrals be bonded together?
Not as two separate bonds. Two sets running in parallel form one interconnected system, and that system may have only one neutral-to-earth bond in total; two bonds put a standing current on the earthing path and upset the earth-fault protection. Two sets that change over rather than run together are kept apart by switching the neutral, so each bond belongs to one source at a time. The paralleling case is worked through in generator paralleling.
What earth-fault current does a generator produce?
It is limited by the alternator and is far smaller than a transformer’s, typically a few times the rated current and decaying within a few cycles rather than being held up. A 400 V, 500 kVA set has a rated current of about 722 A per phase, and the earth-fault current on that machine may be in the low thousands of amps for the first few cycles and then fall away. That is why earth-fault protection is set low, often between 10 and 20 % of rated current with a delay of 0.5 to 5 seconds, rather than relying on the overcurrent device alone.
Send the system, not only the rating
Give us the single-line diagram and the earthing system, and answer one question: does the neutral go through the changeover? Add whether the board has an RCD or an earth-fault relay, whether the set will be a separately derived system, whether the load includes a UPS or a large harmonic load, and whether the set will run in parallel. The reply carries the neutral arrangement for the quotation, the number of poles for the changeover, and the protective-device coordination for that board.
Written and maintained by the KVA Grid sales engineering desk. The earthing systems and the neutral arrangements described here are the principles and the order in which the decisions are taken; the arrangement itself is fixed by a qualified electrical designer for the specific installation and the local wiring rules, and on a combined neutral and earth supply the distributor’s own rules have to be confirmed rather than assumed. The changeover decision is set out from the switch side in ATS vs AMF, the relay settings in generator control panel and protections, the neutral conductor sizing in generator cable sizing and voltage drop, and the single-bond rule for more than one machine in generator paralleling. Nothing on this page is a quotation for a particular project. Reviewed 9 October 2026.
