An ATS is the switch that moves the load from the mains to the generator. AMF is the control function that notices the mains has failed and tells the generator to start; a panel sold as an AMF panel normally contains both. The decisions that actually change the price and the behaviour of the site are the current rating, three poles or four, contactors or circuit breakers, open or closed transition, and the delays that decide how long the site stays dark.
The switch and the function are two different things
A transfer switch has two inputs and one output: the mains on one side, the generator on the other, and the load on the common terminal. Mechanically it can only be in one of two positions – source I or source II – and a mechanical interlock plus an electrical interlock make sure the two sources can never be closed onto each other. That interlock is the safety function: it is what stops a generator feeding back into a dead utility line while somebody is working on it.
AMF is the function that watches the mains and decides. It monitors voltage, frequency and phase sequence, starts the engine, waits until the set is at rated voltage and frequency, commands the transfer, and reverses the whole sequence when the mains comes back. In a standby package the two functions are normally built into one enclosure, which is why the market uses the names almost interchangeably.
| Question | ATS (automatic transfer switch) | AMF (automatic mains failure) |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A switching device | A control function, normally supplied as a panel |
| What it contains | Contacts, operating mechanism, interlocks, position indication | Controller, mains monitoring, start and stop logic, timers, alarms |
| What it decides | Which source feeds the load | When the set starts, when the load transfers, when it transfers back, when the set stops |
| What it needs to work | A command, automatic or manual | A switching device to act on |
| How it is quoted | By current rating and poles, as a wall-mounted or floor-standing assembly | As an AMF panel, an AMF-ATS panel, or the control panel on the set |
One question sorts out most quotations: which device gives the start command? If the supplier quotes an ATS with no mains monitoring, something else has to tell the engine to run – a BMS contact, an operator, or a controller on the set. If nobody can answer, the package will switch but it will not start by itself. The 100 kVA class, where this question comes up most often, is covered in 100 kVA diesel generators.
The transfer sequence, and the delays to agree
A transfer is not one event, it is a sequence of seven, and each one has a timer that somebody has to set. The ranges below are the ones that turn up in enquiries; they are adjustable project by project, and they are not a standard.
| Step | Typical setting | Why it is set that way |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Mains failure is detected | About 1 to 3 s | Too short and a voltage dip starts the set; too long and the site is dark for no reason |
| 2. Engine starts and reaches rated voltage and frequency | About 5 to 15 s | Depends on set size, pre-lubrication and any preheat; a large set takes longer than a small one |
| 3. Load transfers to the generator | About 1 to 5 s after the set is ready | Lets the voltage and frequency settle before the load is applied |
| 4. Total restoration of the essential supply | About 8 to 15 s from the mains failure | The figure a hospital essential board is designed around, and the one to promise the client |
| 5. Mains return is confirmed | About 1 to 10 min, commonly 3 to 5 min | Stops the site transferring back and forth on a supply that is flapping |
| 6. Load transfers back to the mains | About 1 to 5 s after the window closes | Short, because the mains is already stable by definition |
| 7. Cool-down, then engine stop | About 3 to 5 min at no load | Lets the turbocharger and the windings shed heat before the set stops |
Two of these are worth arguing about at quotation stage. The mains-return window (step 5) is the one that decides whether a site with a poor supply sits on the generator all evening; the cool-down (step 7) is the one that decides whether the turbo lasts. A cool-down set to zero is a cost saving that is paid for later. For what the set is doing while it waits, see prime vs standby power.
Three poles or four: the neutral decision
The most common specification mistake in a transfer switch is decided by one question: does the neutral go through the switch? A three-pole device switches the three phases and leaves the neutral solid; a four-pole device switches the phases and the neutral together.
| Situation | Typical answer | What drives it |
|---|---|---|
| The generator is earthed at the same point as the mains, one earthed system | Three poles are usually enough | There is no parallel neutral path to interrupt |
| The generator is a separately derived system with its own neutral-to-earth bond | Four poles | Two bonds on one system put part of the return current on the earth path |
| The essential board has an RCD or an earth-fault relay | Four poles | A solid neutral gives the device a return path it cannot see, and it trips or fails to trip |
| UPS, IT or a large harmonic load on the essential board | Four poles, with the neutral pole rated for the harmonic current | Third-harmonic current in the neutral can approach or exceed the phase current |
| More than one source, such as two sets or a set plus a shore supply | Four poles | Each source has to be isolated completely while it is not in use |
On a four-pole device the neutral has to make and break with the phases – a device that switches the neutral out of step produces the very problem it was bought to prevent. State the requirement, and check the drawing when it arrives rather than the datasheet.
The reason behind that table is the earthing arrangement, and it is worth following once: an interconnected system has exactly one neutral-to-earth bond, and the poles follow from where that bond sits. Generator earthing and the neutral works the decision through in the order it is actually taken, from the system type to the changeover.
What does the switching: contactors, breakers, static
| Device | Typical band | What to know |
|---|---|---|
| Contactor-based ATS | Up to about 630 to 800 A | Compact and the cheapest of the three. Short-circuit withstand comes from the upstream breaker, so the coordination has to be checked, not assumed |
| Motorised circuit breaker or ACB | About 630 A and above | The switching device is also the overcurrent protection; heavier, larger and more expensive |
| Static transfer switch (STS) | Where the load cannot take a break | Semiconductor switching with no moving parts, transferring in about a quarter of a cycle; used downstream of, not instead of, a UPS |
Whatever the technology, the amp figure on the label is only half the specification. The switch has to carry the generator’s full-load current continuously, survive the fault current the site can deliver, and be coordinated with the device upstream of it. Ask for the continuous rating, the short-circuit withstand and the coordination table as one package. A 400 A device is not automatically the right answer for a set whose full-load current is already close to it.
Open transition or closed transition
In an open transition, or break-before-make, switch the load is interrupted while the contacts move: one source is broken before the other is made. This is the usual type, it is what most standby sites have, and the interruption itself lasts a fraction of a second – short compared with the 8 to 15 seconds the whole restoration takes.
A closed transition, or make-before-break, switch overlaps the two sources for a moment so that the load is never interrupted. It can only do that when both sources are present and acceptable, and when they are synchronised: the published synchronising limits are a voltage difference below about 5 per cent, a frequency difference below about 0.2 Hz, a phase angle within about 5 degrees, and an overlap time under about 100 ms. That in turn means the engine has to be held on an isochronous governor, and it means the two sources are briefly in parallel – which normally needs the utility’s agreement.
| Type | Interruption of the load | Where it is used | What it needs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Open transition (break-before-make) | A fraction of a second during the transfer | The usual choice for standby and essential boards | Nothing beyond the switch itself |
| Closed transition (make-before-break) | None while both sources are acceptable | Loads that cannot take even that fraction, and no-break testing without shutting the site down | Synchronising, an isochronous governor and the utility’s agreement |
| Soft loading | None; the load is ramped across | Running the set in parallel with the mains for peak shaving or load curtailment | Synchronising plus load ramp control |
| Static transfer switch | About a quarter of a cycle | IT and UPS-bypass duty, where two independent sources exist | Two acceptable sources and the semiconductors to switch them |
Two things are worth saying plainly. A closed transition switch is not a substitute for a UPS: it removes the interruption of the transfer, not the interruption of the outage, and it has no stored energy of its own. And a closed transition is not the answer to an unreliable mains – if the mains is already gone, the switch falls back to break-before-make operation, because there is nothing to synchronise with. For sites where the transfer itself is the design driver, see data centers and hospitals.
What to put in the specification
| Item | What to ask for |
|---|---|
| Current rating | The continuous rating at or above the generator’s full-load current, and the frame size in amps, not in kVA |
| Poles | Three or four, and whether the neutral is switched; stated on the drawing |
| Withstand and coordination | The short-circuit withstand figure and the coordination with the upstream protective device |
| Transition type | Open or closed, and for closed transition the synchronising relay settings |
| Delays | The seven settings above, written into the order rather than left at factory default |
| Start command | Which device starts the engine, and how a test start is initiated without waiting for an outage |
| Load shedding | Which boards transfer and which are shed, so the set does not see the whole site at once |
| Monitoring | Alarm contacts and a Modbus or BMS interface for unmanned sites; event log for fault finding |
| Certification | Type test evidence for the assembly, and the product standard it is built and tested to |
Low-voltage switchgear of this kind is covered by the IEC 60947 series, and the same panel is usually also supplied against a national listing. The point of asking is not the paperwork itself: an assembly that has been type tested as a package behaves differently under fault from one built on site from parts.
Common mistakes
- Four poles decided too late. The neutral decision is made by the electrical designer before the board is built; discovering it after the enclosure has been fabricated means a new switch, not a new terminal.
- Rated on kVA, installed on amps. A transfer switch is a current device. A set of 400 kVA at 400 V draws about 577 A, so a 630 A frame is the starting point, not a 400 A one.
- No mains-return window. With the retransfer delay left short, a site on a poor supply transfers back, fails, transfers again, and cycles until somebody widens the window.
- Cool-down set to zero. The engine stops hot, the turbo is left without oil pressure, and the repair bill arrives a year later.
- Interlock taken on trust. The mechanical interlock is the safety function. It has to be visible in the drawing and present in the product, not implemented as a timer in the controller.
- Closed transition without the utility or the governor. Both are conditions of the feature working at all, and neither is included in the price of the switch.
- Only one phase monitored. A mains monitor that watches a single phase can miss a lost phase, and the load transfers onto a supply that was never healthy.
When a manual changeover is enough
Not every site needs either device. Where somebody is always on site, the load is not safety-related, and an outage is an inconvenience rather than a cost, a manual three-position switch – source I, off, source II – is the cheapest reliable answer, with no controller to fail and no settings to drift. It becomes the wrong answer the moment the site has to come back on its own: a cold store, a lift with somebody inside, a server room or a ward cannot wait for an operator to walk to the panel. For the duty questions that sit behind this decision, see hotels, hospital generator sizing and containerized generator applications, where the control panel is part of the package.
Questions
What is the difference between an AMF panel and an ATS?
The ATS is the switch that moves the load between the mains and the generator. The AMF is the function that watches the mains, starts the engine and commands the switch. An AMF panel contains both, which is why the names are used interchangeably in quotations; an ATS supplied on its own needs a start command from somewhere else.
Can an ATS work without an AMF controller?
Yes, but it will not start the generator by itself. The switch still transfers when it is told to, so the start signal has to come from a BMS contact, a key switch or an operator. If the site has to restore itself after a mains failure, the controller is not optional.
How long does an ATS take to transfer the load?
The interruption of the transfer itself is a fraction of a second. The figure that matters to the site is the whole sequence, which is typically 8 to 15 seconds from the mains failure to the essential supply being restored, because the engine has to start and reach rated voltage and frequency first.
Do I need a four-pole ATS?
It depends on the earthing arrangement and on what is downstream. A four-pole device is normally specified where the generator is a separately derived system, where the essential board has an RCD or earth-fault protection, where UPS or harmonic-rich loads are involved, or where more than one source exists. The decision is the electrical designer’s, and it has to be made before the board is ordered.
Is a closed transition ATS a substitute for a UPS?
No. A closed transition switch removes the interruption caused by the transfer, not the interruption caused by the outage, and it holds no stored energy. A UPS carries the load through the outage itself; the transfer switch only decides how the load is handed between two sources that are already available.
Can an ATS and AMF panel be added to a set I already own?
Usually yes, if the set has a control panel that accepts a remote start signal, or if a controller can be fitted alongside it. The panel then needs a mains monitoring point, a start harness and the interlocks, and it is worth having the assembly tested as a package rather than commissioned part by part. The set’s own control gear is the other half of the answer, and a container package normally arrives with it already inside – see containerized diesel generators.
Give us the board, not the box
Send the essential-board schedule, the generator rating and whether the neutral has to be switched, and we will specify the transfer switch and the AMF settings with the set.
Written and maintained by the KVA Grid sales engineering desk. The definitions of open and closed transition, the synchronising limits (voltage within about 5 per cent, frequency within about 0.2 Hz, phase angle within about 5 degrees, overlap under about 100 ms) and the behaviour of static transfer switches follow the published description of transfer switch equipment; low-voltage switchgear and control gear is covered by the IEC 60947 series. Delay ranges are typical adjustable values set project by project and are not a guarantee; the rating and settings of the quoted assembly govern. Reviewed 2 October 2026.
